Donna’s Legislation: A New Suicide Prevention Instrument

Donna’s Legislation: A New Suicide Prevention Instrument


Katrina Brees as a baby together with her mom, Donna, Boston, 1979

I wept after I heard Katrina Brees share the story of her mom’s demise on the CBS Morning Present. For greater than a decade, Katrina and her mom, Donna, labored side-by-side producing parades in New Orleans. Her fond recollections of her mother embody “simply her dancing in a parade, simply her feeling the music, feeling the viewers, giving love.”

            However the one that appeared so carefree was a tormented soul, in a relentless battle with bipolar dysfunction. In 2018 she wrote a letter to her psychiatrist:

“Expensive Physician, it has been 9 months since this episode started. I’m not doing effectively. How lengthy should I endure this?”

Katrina’s mom answered her personal query only a few days later. On June 26, 2018, she purchased a gun and fatally shot herself. She did it beneath the Tree of Life, a New Orleans landmark.

“It was essentially the most particular spot she may select,” stated Katrina. “It’s the place lots of our buddies have had weddings. We’ve had funerals there. The house is so sacred. It feels to me like she laid herself on the cathedral of our neighborhood and died there.”

            My tears have been for Katrina, her mom, and all those that have skilled deaths of despair. I’m all too aware of these emotions. Following years of despair and emotions of hopelessness my father took an overdose of sleeping tablets. Fortuitously, he didn’t have a gun. He was hospitalized and finally recovered. I grew up questioning what occurred to my father, when it might occur to me, and what I may do to forestall it from occurring to different households.

            I confronted my very own darkish night time of the soul when my psychological sickness brought about me to quickly lose hope in ever feeling good once more. Fortuitously, with my spouse’s assist, I used to be capable of attain out for assist and get into remedy. I wrote about my experiences in an article, “Being Bipolar: Residing in a World of Fireplace and Ice.”

            Professor Mike Anestis, who appeared with Katrina on the CBS Sunday Morning present, heads up the New Jersey Gun Violence Analysis Middle on the Rutgers College of Public Well being, stated that many individuals survive suicide makes an attempt utilizing different strategies.

“Intentional overdose? Solely 2% to three% of the oldsters who try suicide utilizing an overdose die,”

stated Anestis.

“Virtually 95% of oldsters who use a firearm do. They don’t get a second probability.”

            Once we consider weapons and violence, we regularly consider murder deaths, mass killings, and horrible tragedies like faculty shootings.

“Suicide accounts for wherever from 60% to 65% of all of the gun deaths in the USA in any given 12 months,”

stated Professor Anestis.

“Weapons are the primary explanation for suicide deaths. Greater than half of all suicide deaths in any given 12 months are attributable to self-inflicted gunshot wounds. So, that’s someplace within the neighborhood of 25,000 firearm suicide deaths within the U.S. each single 12 months.”

            In keeping with College of Alabama legislation professor Fred Vars,

“In 2020, there have been 66 gun suicides each day, which is extra folks than died within the worst mass taking pictures in U.S. historical past. And we don’t see it. You understand, it doesn’t make the information. It occurs one individual at a time. Except it’s a celeb, we simply don’t hear about it.”

            However Vars is making an attempt to vary that, elevating consciousness whereas pushing for brand spanking new gun laws. He says there may be “completely” a correlation between stricter gun legal guidelines and fewer suicides. He’s working with Katrina Brees on laws referred to as Donna’s Legislation, named after her mom. It will enable potential gun patrons to place themselves on a “don’t promote” record.

“A person would have the chance to droop their skill to purchase a gun, voluntarily, confidentially put their identify into the already-existing background examine system,” stated Vars. “And in the event that they tried to purchase a gun, that transaction could be denied.”

When requested by the CBS Morning Present’s interviewer,

“Do you’ve confidence that people who find themselves suicidal would voluntarily request to not be offered a gun?”

Professor Vars replied,

“Throughout a suicidal disaster or depressive episode, I feel it’s unlikely that anyone would enroll. However there are lots of people who’ve been in that darkish place who come out the opposite aspect and know they’re a hazard to themselves. It’s extra like an advance directive. Right here, whereas I’m feeling higher, let me put together myself for that, and simply get the gun out of the equation.

Dr. Vars speaks from private, in addition to skilled, expertise. In his e-book, Weapon of Alternative: Combating Gun Violence Whereas Respecting Gun Rights, he shares his personal expertise with despair, bipolar dysfunction, and ideas of suicide earlier in his life.

“I sank right into a deep despair,”

he remembers.

“It was months earlier than I may return to work full time. As a result of I feared hurting myself, I stayed away from the condominium home windows and kitchen knives. Since that point, I’ve been again on the psych ward solely as soon as extra, one other manic episode, confirming my analysis of bipolar dysfunction.”

This makes excellent sense to me. I’d completely put my identify on a “don’t promote” database to guard myself and my family members from the hazard of my making an irrational resolution on the depth of despair somewhat than after I was feeling extra hopeful. I imagine many consumers I work with who’re coping with despair, addictions, and different well being challenges, would additionally need the choice of this type of safety.

Up to now, Donna’s Legislation advocates haven’t but satisfied Congress to behave, however three states, Washington, Utah and Virginia, have handed it, and Maryland lately held hearings. Psychological well being advocate Bryan Barks testified in favor of the legislation, saying,

“This invoice would give folks vulnerable to suicidality the company to make selections about their very own entry to weapons when they don’t seem to be actively suicidal.”

Katrina Brees says there are additionally different instruments we may use to decrease the danger of suicides. In reflecting on her mom’s demise following a 30-year battle with bipolar dysfunction, she questioned why her mom had gone out and bought a gun, since all her life she had been vehemently against them.

In an Op Ed she hopes to have printed she wrote partly:

“My mother died by gun suicide, and he or she couldn’t have completed it with out Google. The day she died, my mother searched methods to grasp herself. She had been battling suicidal ideation introduced on by a drugs aspect impact and was underneath the care of a psychiatrist. A prime advisable article by Google defined that suicide by handgun is statistically extra dependable. 
“In a fragile state, my mother took Google’s recommendation and looked for gun shops close to her. Google then offered instructions to a gun retailer a pair miles away. She purchased the one gun she would ever personal and shot herself. After her demise, I searched Google myself for data on gun suicide. I used to be bombarded by focused commercials encouraging me to purchase a gun. Even the information article about my mother’s demise offered an algorithm-derived commercial telling me the place I may purchase a gun. As if that weren’t sufficient, I noticed commercials suggesting I may get a free gun — and “Purchase Now” choices with native pickup. 
“Google’s enterprise mannequin is incomes income by maximizing click-throughs. It’s not a passive bystander within the enterprise of promoting weapons and different harmful weapons, it’s an lively participant. 
“When contemplating whether or not tech firms ought to be legally responsible for the dangerous content material their algorithms promote, I hope the Supreme Court docket will think about that even when Google will not be technically liable, its failure to direct suicidal searchers to the Nationwide Suicide Prevention Lifeline (988) is a failure of ethical accountability and a hazard to society.” 

For extra data:

To subscribe to my free weekly publication on vital subjects to enhance the well being and wellbeing of your self and your loved ones, be part of me at