South Carolina’s prime courtroom hears arguments on 6-week abortion ban : NPR


South Carolina is the newest state to debate a six-week abortion ban. The state’s Supreme Court docket heard arguments Tuesday.


It has been a 12 months for the reason that U.S. Supreme Court docket handed authority to states to resolve their very own restrictions round abortion. South Carolina is the newest state to contemplate a ban on the process at six weeks’ gestation. The Supreme Court docket in that state heard arguments at the moment over whether or not this proposed ban can take impact. Present legislation there permits for abortions as much as about 20 weeks. South Carolina Public Radio reporter Maayan Schechter was within the courtroom and joins me now. Welcome.


SUMMERS: So only for starters, inform us about this case.

SCHECHTER: Positive. So the case was filed by South Carolina’s two abortion suppliers. One is Deliberate Parenthood, and the opposite is the Greenville Ladies’s Clinic. That is a personal follow that gives well being care to ladies. And legal professionals for these organizations had been in courtroom at the moment, making arguments defending ladies’s entry to reproductive well being care. And once we speak about this case specifically, it is also necessary to contemplate the geography of South Carolina. South Carolina has been – in what many have described it to be – an abortion island. Most of the surrounding states have already got far more restrictive bans on the books, similar to six and 12 weeks in place, and so many Republican lawmakers and state leaders right here didn’t need the state to grow to be what they think about to be an abortion vacation spot. And that is one of many the explanation why these leaders and lawmakers have been so aggressively defending this case all through the courts.

SUMMERS: And I perceive that that is the second try at a six-week abortion ban in South Carolina. Why is the courtroom debating this after they’ve already dominated a ban unconstitutional?

SCHECHTER: Proper. Effectively, that is a completely new courtroom. A key justice who really authored the lead opinion again in January – she retired just lately, and he or she was the one girl on the courtroom. In South Carolina, the obligatory retirement age for judges is 72. And this explicit justice, Kaye Hearn – she turned 72 and due to this fact needed to retire. And since then, she’s actually publicly defended her determination to strike down the legislation. In a single occasion just lately, she was quoted as saying, six weeks is a joke. However now that she’s gone, the courtroom is definitely all male as a result of lawmakers elected her successor, Gary Hill. And due to this fact, the courtroom is now all males. And the legislature thought they’d have higher luck now, in order that they determined to tweak the ban that was beforehand rejected and take a look at once more with a brand-new viewers.

SUMMERS: What had been the arguments you heard at the moment in courtroom?

SCHECHTER: Positive. So the legal professionals representing the abortion suppliers – they argued that nothing actually has modified for the reason that final try at a six-week ban, and so they think about this ban to nonetheless be unconstitutional. A lawyer for Deliberate Parenthood made the purpose at the moment that, for most individuals, it is impossible they will know that they are pregnant this early, saying individuals, quote, “will not be sitting round taking being pregnant assessments each single day.”

The legal professionals on the opposite facet – that may be for the state and the Republican leaders – they argue that they’ve made what they think about important modifications to this invoice. For instance, they eliminated language about ladies with the ability to make a, quote, “knowledgeable alternative.” And that was in response to issues from one justice who was thought-about the swing vote. He had beforehand raised questions concerning the time ladies need to know that they are pregnant and in addition how a lot time they need to decide. And he really made some ambiguous statements throughout at the moment’s listening to, forecasting perhaps a attainable change of coronary heart, saying, quote, “I promise you I am not altering my evaluation, however that doesn’t imply the result is similar.”

SUMMERS: And briefly, inform us what’s subsequent for this legislation?

SCHECHTER: So it’s kind of unclear when the Supreme Court docket goes at hand down the choice. It could possibly be days or perhaps weeks earlier than we’ve a ruling from the Supreme Court docket. However for now, it is at the moment nonetheless authorized to get an abortion in South Carolina till about 20 weeks. Advocates right here have actually been hammering that message, significantly on social media. There may be some irony in that there are literally solely three clinics within the state that provide abortions. And sometimes, they’ve severe backlogs. So regardless of the legislation, entry right here is already restricted.

SUMMERS: Maayan Schechter of South Carolina Public Radio. Thanks.



Copyright © 2023 NPR. All rights reserved. Go to our web site phrases of use and permissions pages at for additional info.

NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by an NPR contractor. This textual content might not be in its closing kind and could also be up to date or revised sooner or later. Accuracy and availability could fluctuate. The authoritative file of NPR’s programming is the audio file.